No justification for proposed drink driving legislation says VFI

No evidence alcohol is the primary cause of fatalities in 51mg-80mg category
• Legislation without enforcement is futile
• Minister should support Public Health (Alcohol) Bill – legislation that will save lives

The Vintners’ Federation of Ireland (VFI) has today (12th April) stated Minister for Transport Shane Ross is misleading the public in his attempts to introduce changes to drink driving legislation. The VFI also said enforcement of current legislation is the most effective method of reducing road fatalities.

Speaking before the Joint Oireachtas Transport Committee regarding the Road Traffic (Fixed Penalty – Drink Driving) Bill 2017, VFI Chief Executive Padraig Cribben said:

“The primary document that is currently being used in relation to this proposal is a report from the Road Safety Authority entitled “Fatal Collisions 2008-2012, Alcohol as a Factor”. It is our belief that a proper analysis of that report will show that there is no justification for the measures being proposed by the Minister.”

Mr Cribben stated that figures in the report revealed 1.3% of road fatalities involved drivers with a Blood Alcohol Content (BAC) level between 51mg-80mg:

“Of course, legislation that would reduce or eliminate this 1.3% would be welcome and justified if there were evidence that in these cases alcohol was a determined cause of the accident. There is no such evidence.”

Other contributory factors cited by the RSA must be considered:

“In 301 of the 330 alcohol related collisions, other behavioural contributory factors in combination with alcohol include speed, drugs, dark clothing, dangerous behaviour, fatigue and distraction.” – RSA report

After thorough analysis of the RSA report, the VFI Chief Executive said:

“What we have is evidence of a presence of alcohol but no evidence that alcohol is the cause. These are two very different things.”

The RSA report states that alcohol was the sole contributory factor in 11% of collisions yet no evidence is provided to say if any of the 11% fall into the 51mg-80 mg category or indeed which category they fall into.

The VFI Chief Executive went on to say the increase in road fatalities since 2012 can, in part, be attributed to a major increase in commercial activity leading to significantly more traffic on the roads.

“At the same time there has been a corresponding significant reduction in Garda presence in the Garda Traffic Corps. The conclusion does not demand rocket science.”

He also rejected the minister’s statement last week to the Joint Oireachtas Transport Committee that Vintners were engaging in “cynical” self-interest.

“We are certainly not prepared to take a lecture on cynicism from a Minister who comes into this Committee and makes a virtue of doing something that he says will save lives (which we dispute) while at the same time opposing a Bill (Public Health (Alcohol) Bill), that all medical commentators can confirm will save lives, because he says ‘of the effect it will have on retailers. It could well put some of them out of business’. That is cynicism in the extreme.”


Press Contact
Brian Foley
Communications & Public Affairs Manager
Email: [email protected]
Tel: +353 1 492 3400
Mobile: +353 (0)86 2690 281